Scammers are constantly evolving their tactics, targeting our community through phone calls, texts, emails, and in-person schemes. This page is updated regularly with the latest scams reported by our members, local law enforcement, and consumer protection agencies. Awareness is one of your strongest defenses — the more you know, the harder it is for scammers to succeed.
Experiencing fraud or a scam on your MCU accounts right now? Click here for immediate next steps.
Use this form to report a scam that we can share with the community.
FTC Report Fraud — reportfraud.ftc.gov
CFPB Consumer Help — consumerfinance.gov
Identity Theft Help — identitytheft.gov
Madison Police Department — cityofmadison.com/police
Madison Credit Union — 608-266-4750
Debit Card After Hours — 1-888-263-3370
MCU Credit Card Elan — 1-800-558-3424
Recent Scam Alerts
Fraudulent Calls Impersonating Madison Credit Union – “Security Check”
Status : Active
Scam Type : Phone Call
Scam Source : Member Reported
Madison Credit Union members are urged to remain vigilant against phone scams involving individuals falsely claiming to represent the credit union.
A member recently reported receiving a phone call from individuals claiming to be checking the security of her phone. The callers requested personal information and then sent an icon that reportedly allowed them to access the member’s phone and personal information. The scammers also instructed the member to download apps, use various companies to make purchases, buy gift cards, and send photos of the gift cards.
Please remember:
- Madison Credit Union will never ask you to purchase gift cards and send photos of them as a form of payment or verification.
- Never share sensitive personal information, passwords, security codes, or account credentials with unsolicited callers.
- Do not click on unfamiliar links, open unexpected attachments, download apps, or tap icons sent by unknown individuals.
- Be cautious of anyone pressuring you to make purchases, buy gift cards, or take immediate action over the phone.
- If you receive a suspicious call claiming to be from Madison Credit Union, hang up and contact us directly at (608) 266-4750.
Reported phone numbers associated with this incident:
- 904-431-8710
- 919-691-3808
If you believe you have been targeted by this scam or have shared personal information, downloaded an unfamiliar app, or granted someone access to your phone, please contact Madison Credit Union immediately for assistance securing your accounts and personal information.
Stay alert, protect your information, and when in doubt, contact us directly.
Fake Facebook Marketplace Listing With Your Name — Do Not Reply
Status : Active
Scam Type : Social Media/Online/Message
Scam Source : Industry Reported
A text message pops up on your phone asking “Is this still available for purchase?” Attached is a picture of what appears to be a Facebook Marketplace listing with your name on it as the seller. Your instinct may be to reply immediately to correct the mistake — but that is exactly what the scammer is counting on.
The listing is completely fake. Cybercriminals create phony Marketplace listings using real names gathered from public social media profiles and send the message to the matching phone number. The goal is not to buy anything — it is simply to get you to respond.
Replying to the message confirms to the scammer that your phone number is active. An active verified number is valuable — it can be sold to other scammers who will use it to attempt to hack your device, take over your Facebook account, or target you with additional scams.
What to do:
- Do not reply — even to correct the mistake or tell them it isn’t you
- Do not click any links attached to the message
- Block and delete the message
- Limit the personal information you share publicly on social media — cybercriminals use details like your name and phone number to make their messages appear legitimate
- If you receive a suspicious message from someone you know, verify it by contacting them through a different method before responding
Report suspicious messages to the FTC at reportfraud.ftc.gov and to Facebook directly at facebook.com/help.
AI Voice Cloning Investment Scam
Status : Active
Scam Type : Phone Scam
Scam Source : Member Reported
A family connected to our credit union was recently targeted by a sophisticated AI voice cloning scam. An elderly man received a phone call from what he believed to be his daughter’s voice urging him to make changes to his IRA investments. The voice was so convincing that he did not question who was calling — because it sounded exactly like her. It wasn’t until he spoke with his daughter directly that he realized she had never made that call.
In this case the member did not have an IRA, which was the detail that ultimately didn’t add up. But the scenario was far from random — scammers often target older adults whose adult children regularly help them manage their finances, making a call like this entirely plausible. Had the account existed, the consequences could have been severe.
Scammers are now using artificial intelligence to clone the voices of real people using as little as a few seconds of audio. You may not even realize you’ve provided it. Voice samples can be harvested from social media videos, voicemails, public recordings, telemarketing calls, spam calls, and even what appear to be accidental misdials — all designed to capture your voice without your knowledge. That recording is then used to create a near perfect clone that can fool even the people who know you best.
Red flags to watch for:
- An unexpected call from a family member about financial matters
- References to accounts or investments you don’t recognize
- Urgency around wire transfers or account changes
- Requests to keep the call confidential from other family members
What you can do right now:
- Establish a secret family code word that anyone asking for money must provide before you act
- If something feels off, hang up and call your family member back directly on their known number — even if the voice sounds right
- Never make changes to any financial account based on a phone call alone
- If you have elderly parents, talk to them about this scam today — the conversation could protect their life savings
If you or a family member were targeted by a scam like this, report it to the FTC at reportfraud.ftc.gov, the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center at ic3.gov, and Wisconsin DATCP at ConsumerProtection.wi.gov or 800-422-7128. If an older adult was targeted, contact the Aging & Disability Resource Center of Dane County at 608-261-9930 to report potential elder financial exploitation. You can also always call us at 608-266-4750 and we can help guide you to the right resources.
Fake Discover/Capital One Customer Service Call
Status : Active
Scam Type : Phone Scam
Scam Source : Member Reported
A Madison Credit Union member recently reported receiving a call from someone claiming to be a Discover customer service representative regarding suspicious transactions on their account. The caller ID displayed “Discover Bank” making the call appear completely legitimate.
The scammer referenced the real and widely publicized Capital One acquisition of Discover, using the transition as a reason to verify account information. The caller was calm, professional, and reassuring — showing none of the high pressure urgency typically associated with scam calls. The member was asked to provide their online banking login credentials and debit card information.
Scammers are using the merger as a pretext to trick customers into revealing sensitive information. They may call, text, or email claiming you must “verify your account,” “reactivate your Discover card,” or “update login details” due to the transition.
This scam is particularly dangerous because:
- The caller ID was spoofed to show a real bank name
- The Capital One/Discover acquisition is a real event, making the story believable
- The caller’s calm demeanor did not trigger typical scam warning instincts
Remember: No legitimate bank — including Discover, Capital One, or Madison Credit Union — will ever call you and ask for your online banking username, password, or full debit card number. Ever. If you receive a call like this, hang up immediately and call the number on the back of your card directly.
If you provided your information to a caller like this, contact us immediately at 608-266-4750. Time is critical.
“Jessica” from Tax Consultants of America
Status : Active
Scam Type : Phone Scam
Scam Source : Member Reported / BBB Confirmed / Spectrum News Wisconsin
UPDATE: The calls are now coming from a variety of names, not just Jessica.
Wisconsin residents are receiving voicemails from someone named “Jessica” claiming to be from “Tax Consultants of America” regarding urgent tax balances or unfiled returns. This is a well documented scam — do not call back.
The caller leaves an urgent voicemail claiming there are unresolved tax balances or unfiled returns that need immediate attention, sometimes referencing a partial account number or phone number to make the message seem legitimate. The goal is to pressure you into calling back before a supposed deadline, at which point scammers will attempt to collect your Social Security number, bank account information, or other sensitive personal information.
Red flags to watch for:
- Urgent language about “time sensitive” tax matters
- A callback number that answers as a different company name than the one that called you
- Pressure to act immediately before a deadline
- Any request for personal or financial information over the phone
The IRS and legitimate tax professionals will never contact you out of the blue by phone demanding immediate action. If you have genuine concerns about your taxes, contact the IRS directly at irs.gov or call a local licensed tax professional.
If you received this call, report it to the FTC at reportfraud.ftc.gov and the BBB at bbb.org/scamtracker.
The Mortgage Lien Holder Scam
Status : Active
Scam Type : Mail Scam
Scam Source : Member Reported
After completing a second mortgage with us, one of our members received an official-looking letter, seemingly addressed from “Madison CU” with “IMPORTANT” marked on the front. The letter included their mortgage ID number, loan amount, county, and closing date. It wasn’t from us. Buried in the fine print was a disclosure stating the letter had no affiliation with any bank, lender, or lending institution and that all information was obtained through public records.
When you refinance or purchase a new mortgage, the new loan is recorded in your county’s property records to secure the lien. Scammers or predatory marketers monitor these public filings, pull your loan details (like the loan amount, lender’s name, or mortgage number), and send official-looking letters to scare you into buying unnecessary services.
- Hidden fees: Offers to buy a copy of your deed or lien release at an extreme markup (you can get these directly from your county recorder for a few dollars).
- Fictitious services: Solicitations for “mortgage protection,” “bi-weekly payment programs,” or “home warranties” that are completely unrelated to your actual loan.
- Impersonation: Letters using alarming language or making it look like it’s a mandatory notice from your “Lien Holder” or “Current Lender”.
If you have recently closed on a mortgage or refinance, watch your mailbox carefully. When in doubt, call us directly to verify.
The Fake Wisconsin DMV Test
Status : Active
Scam Type : Text Message
Scam Source : In the News
Scammers are sending texts warning of a “Driver’s License Suspension Pending” or vague “violation details” with a demand for urgent action and a link that takes you to unofficial websites designed to steal your personal information. Some of these fake sites closely mimic official WisDOT pages. Wisconsin DMV will never text you an unsolicited payment demand. Delete the message and do not click any links.
Wisconsin DMV urges consumers to be on the lookout and follow these tips:
- Be suspicious of demands for immediate action, personal information or money.
- Do not share personal information with unsolicited emails or messages.
- If you have not signed up to receive email or text messages from DMV and receive an unsolicited text message or email from an unknown number or person, do not respond, engage with the caller or click on links.
- Sign up for account activity alerts and renewal reminders by subscribing to Wisconsin DMV’s eNotify. Like most bank accounts, you will receive confirmation of transactions on your account which alerts you of any fraudulent activities. Sign up for eNotify here: wisconsindmv.gov/enotify https://wisconsindot.gov/Pages/online-srvcs/renew-licens/enotify-default.aspx
The Utility Imposter Scam
Status : Widespread
Scam Type : Phone Call
Scam Source : Wisconsin DATCP
Wisconsin residents are receiving phone calls from someone impersonating their utility provider, claiming their account is overdue and threatening to disconnect service unless they pay immediately. Real utility companies contact overdue accounts multiple times by mail before ever threatening disconnection.
Wisconsin consumers or businesses who receive a message about overdue utility bills should end the call or ignore the message. After that, the consumer should verify that their utility account is not overdue by logging into their online account or calling their provider using trusted contact information from a previous bill or the company’s official website.
While recent reports mostly involve phone calls, consumers and businesses may also be contacted by email or text message and should approach those messages with the same skepticism.
Red flags to watch for: demands for payment via barcode at a retail store, cryptocurrency, gift cards, or wire transfers. If you get one of these calls, hang up and call your utility provider directly using the number on your bill.
Learn more at the Department of Agriculture, Trade, and Consumer Protection’s full post here.
The Storm Chaser Contractor Scam
Status : Active
Scam Type : In Person
Scam Source : City of Madison
Following recent severe storms in Madison, the City is warning residents about disreputable contractors going door to door offering storm repair services. These “storm chasers” pressure homeowners into quick decisions and often take payment without completing the work. Always contact your insurance provider first, hire established local contractors, and get everything in writing before any work begins.
Learn more at the City of Madison’s full post here. It includes ways to protect yourself contact information for the Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection.
The West Side Gym Parking Lot Theft
Status : Active
Scam Type : In Person
Scam Source : Madison Police Department
Madison Police are seeing a surge of card thefts from unlocked vehicles near the Crunch Fitness location on Mineral Point Road and the West Towne Mall area. At least 20 cards have been stolen since the start of the year, with fraudulent purchases made within an hour of the theft in half of those cases. Always lock your car, and never leave your wallet or cards in your vehicle — even for a quick workout.
Learn more at the Madison Police Department’s full post here.
Fake Law Enforcement / Cryptocurrency Kiosk Scam
Status : Active
Scam Type : Phone Call
Scam Source : Dane County Sheriff’s Office / Governor Evers AB 968
Scammers posing as local law enforcement are calling residents and claiming they have a warrant, missed jury duty, or owe back taxes. They demand immediate payment — often directing victims to deposit cash at a cryptocurrency kiosk (Bitcoin ATM) located at a local gas station or convenience store. Once that money is deposited it is virtually untraceable and unrecoverable.
Wisconsin now has more than 700 cryptocurrency kiosks across the state, and investigations have shown that more than 9 in 10 uses of crypto kiosks are fraudulent. Governor Evers signed a new law on April 9, 2026 that puts daily transaction limits at $1,000 and requires operators to reimburse victims who report scams to law enforcement within 30 days.
The Dane County Sheriff’s Office wants residents to know that law enforcement will never ask for money over the phone or by email. If you receive a call like this, hang up immediately and call your local authorities directly using a verified number. Never deposit cash into a cryptocurrency kiosk at the direction of someone you don’t know.
Source: Dane County Sheriff’s Office — danesheriff.com | Wisconsin AB 968 — wisbusiness.com
The Bail Money Scam
Status : Active
Scam Type : Phone Scam
Scam Source : Member Reported
One of our members recently received an urgent call — someone claiming the member’s grandson had been arrested and needed bail money right away. The caller sounded official and convincing, and our member unknowingly confirmed some personal information before realizing what was happening.
When the caller asked for bank account information, our member paused and said he wanted to call his credit union first. The caller became agitated, pushed urgency, and told him not to call — and that’s when our member hung up and called us instead. He did exactly the right thing.
Scammers can get a lot of information just off of someone’s social media feed, they use this information to make the story sound more legitimate. That bail money scam is often used on grandparents.
Remember: If anyone pressures you not to contact your bank or credit union, that is your biggest red flag. Hang up and call us first — always.
I think I’ve been scammed — now what?
Hang up. Do not send any more money. Block the phone number or email.
Do not delete any text or email in case it can be used for proof later.
Call us immediately at 608-266-4750.
If you used your debit card, go to the mobile app and turn your debit card off and call us. If it is after hours, the debit card number is: 1-888-263-3370
File a report with the FTC at reportfraud.ftc.gov. For identity theft, visit identitytheft.gov. Contact Madison PD if you were physically threatened or if cash was taken.
Consider placing a free credit freeze at the three bureaus (Equifax, Experian, TransUnion).
Change any reused passwords.
Enable two-factor authentication on your accounts.
Sign-up for account alerts and debit card alerts.



